Saw you again for the first time, in a long time.
It brought out all these feelings that I never knew I had inside.
Seeing you with another girl, it didn't sit with me too well.
And I'm mad at myself 'cause I love you,
And with or without you I'm goin' through hell!

Refrain:
I don't think that I could shake ya,
So baby, can we make up (yeah!)
I know that this is kind of crazy (crazy),
But baby (yeah), I wanna make up.

Refrain

I never knew I could love you, how I love you.
I thought that I was through with you, so glad that I could be single
Now I'm caught thinkin' 'bout the past,
And wish that we could just go back.
And I'm mad at myself 'cause I love you,
And I really want you to come on back!

Refrain

Refrain

I don't know if I'm crazy,
But all pain and the heartache you gave me,
That only made me, wanna get back with you, ooh-ooh-ahh-ohh...
You held her hand the way yah held mine,
Yah felt her, uhh, the way yah felt mine,
And all the fightin' that we went through,
See, I was already used to it.

Refrain (4x)

Ohhhh...
La-la-la-la-ohhh...
I don't know what you did to me, boy...
But I want you to come...
Come back now or I'll go crazy, crazy,
Crazy, crazy!